Appeals

No Appeal (Rule 70.5) Procedures

US Sailing’s Prescription to rule 70.5(a) requires approval if the right of appeal is to be denied when “it is essential to determine promptly the result of a race that will qualify a boat to compete in a later stage of an event or a subsequent event.”

The document below discusses the process by which US Sailing’s permission may be granted and the requirements an Organizing Authority and Protest Committee must comply with in order to balance the need for certainty of results while protecting competitors’ rights as much as possible.

Procedure for Reopening a Hearing at a “No Appeal” Area Qualifier

The following language must be in the Sailing Instructions and Notice of Race of all qualifiers for US Sailing Championships. This will apply to all protests and requests for redress involving those sailors moving on, not just those sailing for the finals because any party can be party to a protest. (In other words, a sailor who is not sailing for the championship qualifier protesting against someone who is because it could change the results.)

PROTEST AND APPEALS

  • Under rule 70.5(a), there shall be no appeal of the decision of a protest or request for redress. However, a decision following a hearing under rule 69.1(a) may be appealed.
  • Email and phone contact information for the helm of each boat entered and for the chairmen of the Protest Committee and the Race Committee shall be posted on the official notice board at all times during the event.
  • Rule 65.2 is changed as follows:
    • 65.2 A party to the hearing is entitled to receive the above information in writing, provided she asks for it in writing and hand-delivers her request to a member of the protest committee no later than the protest time limit on the last day of racing or one hour after being informed of the decision, whichever is later. The committee shall then, within two hours, hand-deliver the information to the party, including when relevant, a diagram of the incident prepared or endorsed by the committee.

REOPENING A HEARING – Rule 66 is Changed

  • 66.1 The protest committee may reopen a hearing when it decides that it may have made a significant error, or when significant new evidence becomes available within a reasonable time. A party to the hearing may ask for a reopening no later than 24 hours after being informed of the decision. When a hearing is reopened, a majority of the members of the protest committee shall, if possible, be members of the original protest committee.
  • 66.2 Area Qualifier Reopening
  • 66.2(a) A party to a hearing of a protest or request for redress may request an Area Qualifier Reopening. The request shall be in writing and include the significant error that the party believes the protest committee made or the nature of the significant new evidence that is available. The request shall be made no later than 24 hours after the hearing or 24 hours after the protest time limit on the last day of racing, whichever is later. The request, along with copies of the original protest or request for redress, the facts found, the decision of the protest committee, any new evidence that cannot be presented verbally, and email and phone contact information for all parties to the hearing as well as the chairman of the protest committee, shall be sent by e‐mail to the US Sailing Championships staff, and the US Sailing Adult Championships Chair, Drew Daugherty, for adult events, or the US Sailing Youth Championships Chair, Malinda Crain, for youth events. The hearing shall be reopened when the foregoing information is received by the Director and Chair.
  • 66.2(b) The protest committee for an Area Qualifier Reopening shall consist of the chairman of the original protest committee plus four certified judges appointed by US Sailing. A majority of the committee’s members shall be Senior or International Judges. US Sailing will appoint its chairman.
  • 66.2(c) An Area Qualifier Reopening will be conducted by telephone conference call. The time and date for the conference call shall be established by the chairman as soon as practicably possible and no later than seven days after the request for reopening is emailed. The chairman will email to the parties to the hearing the request for reopening, the facts found, the decision of the protest committee, the time and date of the hearing, the process for joining the call and any other relevant documents.

For more information, please contact the Race Administration Director by email or by phone at 1-800-877-2451.

No Appeal (Rule 70.5) Procedure
Reopening Procedure for Area Qualifiers

 

Approved No-Appeal Events under Rule 70.5(a)

The following events have been granted permission by US Sailing to deny the right of appeal under rule 70.5(a):

2018 Baldwin Cup (Qualifying Series) – April 11-14, 2018

Venue: Newport Harbor Yacht Club, Newport Beach, CA
US Sailing contact: NA

2018 Optimist Team Trials (Qualifying Series and Finals) – April 21-29, 2018

Venue: Key Biscayne Yacht Club, Key Biscayne, FL
US Sailing contact: Means Davis – IJ

2018 Optimist National Championship – July 13-18, 2018

Venue: Pensacola Yacht Club, Pensacola, FL
US Sailing contact: Stephen Wrigley – IJ, IU

2018 470 National Championship – July 14-15, 2018

Venue: Oakcliff Sailing, Oyster Bay, NY
US Sailing contact: Stephen Wrigley – IJ, IU

2018 Area K Smythe/Bemis/Sears Qualifier for the Chubb Junior Championship – July 17, 2018

Venue: Sheboygan Yacht Club, Sheboygan, WI
US Sailing contact: Don Becker – IJ, IU

2018 Optimist Team Race National Championship – July 19-22, 2018

Venue: Pensacola Yacht Club, Pensacola, FL
US Sailing contact: Means Davis – IJ

2018 Thistle National Championship (Qualifying Series) – July 30 – August 3, 2018

Venue: Cedar Point Yacht Club, Westport, CT
US Sailing contact: Sandy Grosvenor – IRO, IJ, IU

2018 International Naples Sabot Junior Championship – (Qualifying Series) – August 6-9, 2018

Venue: Long Beach Yacht Club, Long Beach, CA
US Sailing contact: Bruce Cook – IJ, IU

2018 Resolute Cup (Qualifying Series) – September 10-15, 2018

Venue: New York Yacht Club, Newport, RI
US Sailing contact: Stephen Wrigley – IJ, IU

2018 Red Bull Foiling Generation US Qualifier – November 2-4, 2018

Venue: Red Bull North America, Key Biscayne, FL
US Sailing contact: Pat Healy – IJ

2018 DF95 Global Invitational Championship (Qualifying Series) – November 3-10, 2018

Venue: Trinity River Yacht Club / AMYA #10, Dallas, TX
US Sailing contact: Don Becker – IJ, IU

2018 Optimist Midwinter Championship – November 21-24, 2018

Venue: Southern Yacht Club, New Orleans, LA
US Sailing contact: Darryl Waskow – IJ

 

Blanket Permission Events Under Rule 70.5

All events hosted by, and limited to members of, the following organizations are granted blanket permission to deny the right of appeal and a waiver of the requirements concerning composition of protest committees, provided that the denial of appeal is stated in the Notice of Race and Sailing Instructions and is clearly posted on the official notice board:

Inter-Scholastic Sailing Association (ISSA) & Inter-Collegiate Sailing Association (ICSA)

Additionally, Area-qualifying events for US Sailing Championships are granted blanket permission to deny the right of appeal under rule 70.5(a) and a waiver of the requirements concerning composition of protest committees as required by US Sailing’s No-Appeal process, provided that: 1) the denial of appeal is stated in the Notice of Race and Sailing Instructions, 2) the Area Re-Opening Procedure requirements are met, and 3) the requirements for appointment of race officials in US Sailing Regulation 10 are met. However, a decision resulting from a hearing under rule 69.2 may be appealed.

Procedure for Reopening a Hearing at a “No Appeal” Area Qualifier

The following language must be in the Sailing Instructions and Notice of Race of all qualifiers for US Sailing Championships. This will apply to all protests and requests for redress involving those sailors moving on, not just those sailing for the finals because any party can be party to a protest. (In other words, a sailor who is not sailing for the championship qualifier protesting against someone who is because it could change the results.)

PROTEST AND APPEALS

  • Under rule 70.5(a), there shall be no appeal of the decision of a protest or request for redress. However, a decision following a hearing under rule 69.1(a) may be appealed.
  • Email and phone contact information for the helm of each boat entered and for the chairmen of the Protest Committee and the Race Committee shall be posted on the official notice board at all times during the event.
  • Rule 65.2 is changed as follows:
    • 65.2 A party to the hearing is entitled to receive the above information in writing, provided she asks for it in writing and hand-delivers her request to a member of the protest committee no later than the protest time limit on the last day of racing or one hour after being informed of the decision, whichever is later. The committee shall then, within two hours, hand-deliver the information to the party, including when relevant, a diagram of the incident prepared or endorsed by the committee.

REOPENING A HEARING – Rule 66 is Changed

  • 66.1 The protest committee may reopen a hearing when it decides that it may have made a significant error, or when significant new evidence becomes available within a reasonable time. A party to the hearing may ask for a reopening no later than 24 hours after being informed of the decision. When a hearing is reopened, a majority of the members of the protest committee shall, if possible, be members of the original protest committee.
  • 66.2 Area Qualifier Reopening
  • 66.2(a) A party to a hearing of a protest or request for redress may request an Area Qualifier Reopening. The request shall be in writing and include the significant error that the party believes the protest committee made or the nature of the significant new evidence that is available. The request shall be made no later than 24 hours after the hearing or 24 hours after the protest time limit on the last day of racing, whichever is later. The request, along with copies of the original protest or request for redress, the facts found, the decision of the protest committee, any new evidence that cannot be presented verbally, and email and phone contact information for all parties to the hearing as well as the chairman of the protest committee, shall be sent by e‐mail to the US Sailing Championships Director, Betsy Alison, and the US Sailing Championships Chair, swmadero@aol.com. The hearing shall be reopened when the foregoing information is received by the Director and Chair.
  • 66.2(b) The protest committee for an Area Qualifier Reopening shall consist of the chairman of the original protest committee plus four certified judges appointed by US Sailing. A majority of the committee’s members shall be Senior or International Judges. US Sailing will appoint its chairman.
  • 66.2(c) An Area Qualifier Reopening will be conducted by telephone conference call. The time and date for the conference call shall be established by the chairman as soon as practicably possible and no later than seven days after the request for reopening is emailed. The chairman will email to the parties to the hearing the request for reopening, the facts found, the decision of the protest committee, the time and date of the hearing, the process for joining the call and any other relevant documents.

Reopening Procedure for Area Qualifiers