RESULTS

The results are broken down by area tested.  The sites had been initially selected based upon Washington State, Corps of Engineers and NOAA charts for differing soil conditions and were then surveyed on April 22 by diver Montgomery during a reconnaissance.  Additional underwater site checks were conducted during testing to confirm bottom characteristics.

Site 1.  Off Point Monroe and entrance to Port Madison.  Bottom consists of some scattered eel grass, kelp, and mostly sand.  This was a good holding area for most anchors.  There was some unevenness in the area which caused difficulty in maintaining scope at 5:1 when some anchors were pulled into deeper water.

Table 1
Results Straight Pull - Site #1

Anchor

Maximum Line Tension Before Dragging

Luke 50 (53 lbs) 1

Slow drag to 440

Slow drag to 360

Slow drag to 300

Slow drag to 240

Slow drag to 300

Slow drag to 280

 

 

 

 

Bruce 44 (45 lbs.)2

780

580

680

600

600

530

700

560

 

 

Davis 45 (45 lbs.)3

No Set

No Set

No Set

No Set

No Set

No Set

No Set

No Set

 

 

CQR 45 (47 lbs.)2

350

500

1400

1100

1800

3200

No Set4

No Set4

No Set4

No Set4

Delta 35 (35 lbs.)2

900

600

950

800

1100

600

600

1100*

 

 

MAX 17 (43 lbs.)

1016

1334

3110**

5004

 

 

 

 

 

 

Performance 35 (40 lbs.)

1100

2200

3100*

1600

2330* 

 

 

 

 

 

Fortress 37 (24 lbs.)

 

No Set

710

4100*

4100*

2400

4510*

4205*

 

 

*No drag at maximum applied strain.

**Bent fluke.

1 Observers felt that the Luke moved more or less slowly and consistently at all times up to the time it broke free.  In general they felt they were never confident the anchor had actually set.

2 The Bruce, Delta, MAX and Performance 35 set every time.

3 The Davis did not set in ten attempts.

4 These sets were on deep slope areas which presented more difficulty in setting.  This was poor technique and not the fault of the anchors.

 

Table 2
Results on 90-degree Veer Pull - Site #1

Anchor

Maximum Line Tension Before Dragging

 

Luke 50 (53 lbs)

 

Slow drag to 220

Slow drag to 440

Slow drag to 310

 

 

 

 

Bruce 44 (45 lbs.)

 

800

600

860

 

 

 

 

Davis 45 (45 lbs.)3

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

CQR 45 (47 lbs.)2

 

No Set

550

900

1700

1400

1900

2250

Delta 35 (35 lbs.)

950

900

No Set

750

450

400

1000

1050

MAX 17 (43 lbs.)

 

360

3105

No Set

No Set

1300

Several Attempts

2300

Performance 35 (40 lbs.)3

 

 

 

 

Fortress 37 (24 lbs.)

 

4248 1

 

 

 

 

 

 

1 Bent anchor shank and did not repeat veer test.  (Previous straight line set at 4100.)  Anchor did not break out.  See Table 3.

2 No attempts were made on the Davis for the 90-degree veer as it had failed to set in ten consecutive attempts at straight pull.  See Table 1, above.

3 No attempts at 90-degree veer conducted.  The Gilcrest was having some difficulty maneuvering at this point.

Table 3
Results on 180-degree Veer Pull - Site #1

Anchor

Maximum Line Tension Before Dragging

Luke 50 (53 lbs) 1

140

320

350

280

Bruce 44 (45 lbs.)

700

680

600

600

Davis 45 (45 lbs.)2

CQR 45 (47 lbs.)

No Set

No Set

1100

700

1300

800

1100

850

Delta 35 (35 lbs.)

900

1150

No Set

950

No Set

No Set

550

MAX 17 (43 lbs.)

400

900

No Set

No Set

2200

Performance 35 (40 lbs.)

1500

830 3

Fortress 37 (24 lbs.)

4001 4

1 Slow drag in all sets but resistance noted.

2 No 180-degree tests were done with Davis as the anchor had not set in ten consecutive attempts on straight pull test.  See Table 1.

3 Pull into deeper water so scope changed dramatically.

4 Anchor initially set at 4100, then 90-degree at 4248 then 4001 at 180-degree.  Shank bent during process so veer tests with this anchor not repeated.  Underwater view of anchor shows it completely buried in sand initially, with about 4" of fluke out during veering tests.

Site 2.   Off Wing Point in an area of kelp (none detected from surface but indicated on chart)4 small rock and more rocky as it deepened.  A poor holding area for all anchors.  Rocks about fist size and hard glacial clay bottom.  Anchors generally observed by divers as skipping over rocks without being able to penetrate clay.  The larger surface anchors picked up a lot of kelp.

NEXT
BACK TO INDEX